Why India vs Pakistan has lost its lustre as a cricket rivalry
Throughout the history of cricket, India and Pakistan have been embroiled in a competitive rivalry. They have been passionate about the sport for a long time, and since they are neighbouring countries, it is expected that they will compete at a higher level against each other.
The most recent matchup was in the 2025 ICC Champions Trophy on February 23, 2025. It was a fantastic victory for India, winning by six wickets. In recent history, India’s cricket team has been the most successful of the two South Asian countries, and the rivalry has become much more one-sided.
People feel disconnected from the ‘greatest’ rivalry
Due to their status as the best matchup in cricket, people always tune in to watch the passionate rivalry between the two nations. Unfortunately, it has not worked out for them as many are calling their matches ‘snooze fests’.
That is not a good look for the rivalry given that soon, general audiences might follow that notion. Another reason why people are looking down on it is that the actual cricketers who participate in it are also unenthused, like Shubman Gill.
He said, ‘Everyone enjoys watching it. If so many people are happy to watch the match, then who are we to say that it is underhyped or overhyped?’. People considering it overhyped is a big deal as it should serve as an eye-opener for both cricket associations.
The onus falls onto Pakistan more since they have been underperforming. They have a strong history of cricket excellence, but they have not shown that as of late. Pakistan’s cricket team must step up if they want to rekindle this rivalry and improve their standing in the cricket world.
The matchup has been predictable
Pakistan often struggles during their matchups against their rivals. When they get to bat first, they do not ramp up the attack, as they become tentative with their betting. On the opposite end, India's batting first helps them turn up the heat with fast-paced play. That should be how Pakistan takes charge, but they always become slower.
The system must also experience some changes, which fast bowler Hasan Ali has spoken about. He said, ‘For the past four to five years, we have changed around 26 to 27 coaches within the team. It's been true for four years, it's true, it's okay, but when you don’t have stability, these kinds of things happen’.
If Pakistan wants to beat out their rivals, there should be some fundamental changes in their play style. They have talented players, but they should get past the mental block of going against their rivals since India does not care about anything else other than beating Pakistan.
